At Best of Best Review, we recognize companies that don’t just build houses, but build lasting relationships and communities. In the competitive world of home renovation on Long Island, Keenan Custom Homes shines as a beacon of craftsmanship, trust, and personalized service. Awarded Best Home Renovation Expert on Long Island of 2025, this husband-and-wife team has redefined what it means to renovate a home — blending old-world artistry with modern expertise, and above all, heart.

Craftsmanship Rooted in Heritage

Padraig Keenan’s roots in traditional Irish woodworking set Keenan Custom Homes apart from the crowd. Each project bears the unmistakable mark of meticulous attention to detail and a commitment to quality that has been honed over decades. This old-world craftsmanship isn’t just about aesthetics; it’s about durability, precision, and a genuine love for creating something beautiful that will last for generations. Whether it’s intricate trim work or custom cabinetry, Padraig’s expertise brings a timeless elegance to every home he touches.

A Family Business With a Personal Touch

What truly makes Keenan Custom Homes exceptional is the deep personal investment Sara and Padraig bring to every client. As owners and operators, they don’t just delegate — they’re hands-on from start to finish. Homeowners don’t get lost in layers of management or forgotten in the shuffle. Instead, they work directly with a team that cares deeply about their vision and experience. Sara’s leadership ensures open lines of communication, clear timelines, and a warm, collaborative process that feels more like working with trusted family friends than a typical contractor.

This family-centered approach also extends beyond business. Raising four children while running a successful company, Sara and Padraig understand the importance of a home that’s safe, beautiful, and functional. Their empathy and dedication stem from lived experience, adding an unmatched layer of authenticity and care to their work.

Seamless Renovations Backed by Community Trust

Navigating the complexities of permits and inspections can be daunting for any homeowner. Luckily, Keenan Custom Homes’ long-standing relationships with Suffolk County’s town inspectors often streamline this process, reducing delays and frustrations. This local trust comes from years of consistently exceeding code requirements and maintaining impeccable standards. For clients, it means their renovations move forward smoothly and efficiently — a priceless advantage in any home improvement project.

Versatility That Meets Every Need

One of the many strengths of Keenan Custom Homes is their versatility. Whether the task is installing attic stairs, remodeling a kitchen, finishing a basement, or undertaking a full-scale custom home renovation, their dedication never wavers. They offer a comprehensive suite of services, so homeowners can rely on a single, trusted partner throughout their home transformation journey. This breadth of expertise eliminates the hassle of juggling multiple contractors and ensures a cohesive, high-quality result.

What Homeowners Are Saying

Client testimonials speak volumes about Keenan Custom Homes’ professionalism and craftsmanship. One client’s glowing review on Yelp sums it up perfectly: “Workers were always polite. They rebuilt our house after Sandy and everything was beautiful! Excellent craftsmanship.” Such praise reflects not only the technical skills of the team but also their respectful and friendly demeanor — qualities that foster trust and satisfaction.

Why Keenan Custom Homes is the Best

Keenan Custom Homes’ unique combination of authentic Irish craftsmanship, hands-on ownership, and deep community ties has earned them this prestigious award. Unlike large firms where customers can feel like just another job number, Sara and Padraig’s boutique-style business offers the warmth, flexibility, and attention to detail of a family-run company — with the capability to deliver projects of any size.

Their commitment to integrity, quality, and personalized service has cemented their reputation as South Shore’s premier renovation expert. Whether it’s a simple upgrade or a dream home makeover, homeowners can expect a process marked by transparency, expertise, and care.

Looking Ahead

As Keenan Custom Homes continues to grow, Sara and Padraig have exciting plans to expand their design offerings and potentially venture into media projects to share their passion and knowledge with a wider audience. Their vision is to not only build homes but inspire families to create spaces filled with love, craftsmanship, and lasting memories.

For anyone ready to transform their home with confidence, skill, and a personal touch, Keenan Custom Homes stands ready as the trusted partner of choice.

Explore their impressive portfolio and connect with the team at keenancustomhomes.com.