Best of Best Review is proud to recognize Centerville Pie Co Inc with the award for Best Chicken Pie in Massachusetts of 2026. This honor recognizes a company that has elevated a classic comfort food into a beloved culinary experience, earning praise from customers across Massachusetts and throughout the country.

For more than a decade, Centerville Pie Co Inc has built a reputation for crafting exceptional pies that combine homemade flavor, premium ingredients, and consistent quality. At the heart of that success is their famous chicken pie, a product that has become synonymous with comfort, tradition, and excellence.

A Cape Cod Story That Captured National Attention

Founded in 2009 by longtime friends Laurie Bowen and Kristin Broadley, Centerville Pie Co Inc began as a neighborhood pie shop in Cape Cod with a simple mission: create pies that make people feel at home.

That mission quickly resonated with customers. The company's signature chicken pie gained national recognition when Oprah Winfrey selected it as one of her Favorite Things. The distinction introduced the pie to households across America and helped establish Centerville Pie Co Inc as one of the most recognized names in specialty comfort food.

Today, customers from near and far continue to seek out the chicken pie that helped launch the company's success story.

What Makes Their Chicken Pie Stand Out

During the evaluation process, Best of Best Review examined numerous criteria including flavor, ingredient quality, consistency, craftsmanship, customer satisfaction, product innovation, value, brand reputation, convenience, and overall dining experience.

Centerville Pie Co Inc excelled across all categories.

Their signature chicken pie features tender all white meat chicken surrounded by a rich, flavorful filling and enclosed in a flaky golden crust that has become the company's trademark. The combination creates a comforting meal that feels homemade while maintaining remarkable consistency from pie to pie.

Customers frequently praise the balance of flavors, generous portions, and satisfying texture that distinguish the product from traditional grocery store alternatives.

Excellence Built on Craftsmanship

One of the strongest factors behind this recognition is the company's unwavering commitment to craftsmanship. Every pie reflects years of refinement and dedication to quality.

Rather than chasing trends, Centerville Pie Co Inc has focused on perfecting a timeless recipe. The result is a product that appeals to multiple generations, whether served as a family dinner, holiday meal, or thoughtful gift.

This dedication to doing one thing exceptionally well has helped transform their chicken pie into one of Massachusetts' most celebrated comfort foods.

A Brand That Continues to Innovate

While the famous chicken pie remains the cornerstone of the business, Centerville Pie Co Inc continues to expand its offerings to meet evolving customer preferences.

The company recently introduced a collection of Ice Cream Pies featuring flavors such as Strawberry Cheesecake, Salted Caramel, Death by Chocolate, and Mint Chocolate Chip. They have also expanded their grocery line with convenient small savory pies, including Small Chicken Pie, Small Chicken Pot Pie, and Small Shepherd's Pie.

These additions demonstrate a commitment to innovation while preserving the quality and authenticity that customers expect.

Why Best of Best Review Selected Centerville Pie Co Inc

The selection committee considered several key factors when determining this year's winner:

Exceptional flavor and recipe execution.

Consistent product quality.

Strong customer loyalty and satisfaction.

National recognition and media credibility.

Premium ingredients and craftsmanship.

Convenient product availability.

Innovation without sacrificing tradition.

Outstanding reputation throughout Massachusetts.

Memorable customer experience.

Long term commitment to excellence.

Centerville Pie Co Inc distinguished itself in every category, making it a clear choice for this year's recognition.

Best Chicken Pie in Massachusetts of 2026

Best of Best Review proudly names Centerville Pie Co Inc as the Best Chicken Pie in Massachusetts of 2026.

This recognition celebrates a company that has transformed a simple comfort food into an iconic culinary experience. Through exceptional quality, dedication to craftsmanship, and a passion for serving customers, Centerville Pie Co Inc continues to set the standard for chicken pie excellence throughout Massachusetts.

For more information, visit centervillepies.com. Follow Centerville Pie Co. Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube for updates on products, events, and company news.

Kristin Broadley, Owner of Centerville Pie Co Inc, continues to uphold the values of quality, authenticity, and customer satisfaction that have made the company a trusted favorite for customers across the region.